December 10th, 2004


RotK - Extended

Well, that felt like an entire day of my life spent in front of the television. "Highlights" below - I'm just assuming those that care about the differences know about them, else look away...

I did generally liked the extended cut. It's not a lean movie - and some of the fat that has been put back in should really have been left out.

  • Christopher Lee starts off really well, but by the time of his death (moments later) he looks a bit bored with it all. Perhaps he'd been told it wasn't going in the cinematic release.

  • The Witchking vs Gandalf left me wanting more - it had promise - then fizzled. Not sure there was any point in the scene other than explaining why Gandalf lost his staff.

  • Denethor/Faramir remained brilliant. This reminds me that the "Into the West" theme is much better used in the score rather than when being sung.

  • Mouth of Sauron was great - but you can see how it was a nice easy trim.

And was it just my imagination or did Gimli have a serious line?
  • Current Mood
    contemplative contemplative